505 Class Association

for those who like to fly

South African
 

Local

 :: Van Nimwegen results amended :: (369 Reads)

Posted by warwick on Tuesday, October 20, 2009 - 12:13 PM

Following an inspection of the RSA 8481 mainsail before the 2009 Nationals, it was found that the top batten was not in compliance with the class rules. Before the start of the National event the top batten pocket was repositioned in order to comply with the rules. An enquiry from the class measurer, about the status of the mainsail during the previous event, the van Nimwegen regatta, was raised. The skipper of RSA 8481 replied as follows and the van Nimwegen regatta results were corrected.
Dear Sir,

We are apparently in the wrong about the sail in that it did not measure according to the rules. I personally do not agree (that we gained anything) with this, as it would have not made us any faster. Just as Paul Cayard stated in the Yachting magazine, they might have brushed against the guard boat at the start of the third race of the recent SAP 505 Worlds, but did they interfere with the end result of the regatta? They went into a redress hearing and were reinstated into the race.

Our batten was 25mm too high, we did not have any more sail area than anyone else, if anything it was to our disadvantage. We wanted to have the sail measured twice before the event and on both occasions the measurer did not have his measurement equipment with him. I will put this forward as a prerequisite for all measurers to have their measuring equipment with them at every event so that something like this, that could be avoided never happens again!

The class rules state certain measurements of the sail but are subject to interpretation. As Paul Cayard said they brushed the guard boat, which still puts them in the wrong and hence they withdrew from the race. Our sail did not conform to the 505 measurements and therefore we officially withdraw from the regatta out of good sportsmanship.



Regards,

Peter Funke

South African 505 Class President

Following this reply, the results of the van Nimwegen regatta were amended to reflect the retirement of RSA 8481. The ammended results can be found in the results section.
 Printer-friendly page

Van Nimwegen results amended | Log-in or register a new user account | 0 Comments
Comments are statements made by the person that posted them.
They do not necessarily represent the opinions of the site editor.

505 Gallery


Forum Posts

LAST FORUM POSTS
goto Postentry confirmed(3)
 by Thomas
 on 30. Jan at 19:26
goto Post505 racing at Point ...(2)
 by Thomas
 on 22. Jan at 17:24
goto PostRE: new sail plan f...(6)
 by warwick
 on 16. Jan at 05:44
goto PostRSA7722 - Looks grea...(2)
 by warwick
 on 13. Jan at 07:47
goto PostIan Pinnell in a 505...(0)
 by warwick
 on 20. Nov at 19:45

[Access Forum]


Login





 


 Log in Problems?
 New User? Sign Up!